- Abaco Gold
- Beauty Gems
- Becky Thatcher Designs
- Bryan David Jewelers
- Capricorn Jewelry
- Conch Flash
- Conch Key Trading
- Congress Jewelers
- David Brian Jewelers
- Diamonds International
- Dor Jewelry
- Emeralds International Inc
- Gold Creations
- Gold Shoppe
- Italian Jewelers
- Jeff's Gems
- Jewelry Station
- Key West Charms
- Key West Fine Jewelers
- Key West Jewelry Shop
- Key West Treasure Chest
- Lili's On Greene Street
- Linda's Key West
- Little Switzerland
- Local Color
- Mel Fisher's Treasures Sales
- N N Jewelries
- Nautical Treasures
- Neptune Designs
- Sarah Jane Jewelry
- Tanzanite International
- Touch Of Gold
- Whitfield Jack's Jewelry
- Zales The Diamond Store
